Thanks For Your Feedback!

Five plus seven is? (answer as number)

Thank you for your feedback !

How many eyes has a typical person?
Sunday, 27 January 2013 08:02

Does Social Media Provide Sharing, or Just Info Collecting?

Written by

When you ask the question Does Social Media Provide Sharing, or Just Info Collecting? it prompts thought, and in his recent commentary "Social Networks Continue to Push For Control", Thomas Claburn of the Brainyard explores the impact of social media and its integration and impact on your life and business. Is social media required to compete today?


The Internet was supposed to facilitate direct connections between individuals and dis-empower gatekeepers. Instead, it has become a massive man-in-the-middle attack.

Social networking shouldn't be compulsory, and yet it's becoming an obligation. The hunger among Internet companies for data about who you are, what you do, where you go, and who you know keeps growing. They want you to share so they can earn. So they have violated Communication Neutrality: They have made mechanisms for expression into vehicles for marketing, forcing those who participate in online life to promote.

Social networking has become inescapable. Startups often require a Facebook or Twitter login. Google now requires a Google+ account to post app reviews on Google Play. And in many lines of knowledge work, including journalism, participation in these networks has become a job requirement.

The latest entry in the field comes from Microsoft, which has just opened a social network of its own, the aptly named Evidently, the world needs more sharing.

Or it would, if social networks were actually about sharing. The irony of the constant cajoling to share more, of Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg's self-serving predictions that everyone will share more in the future, is that social networks themselves limit how they share the data they've collected. They don't so much share as restrict, through contractual API limitations, through incomplete export capabilities, through burdensome processes, under the pretense of user protection, or to spite the competition.

Consider the latest dustup between Instagram and Twitter. According to the New York Times, Instagram's CEO Kevin Systrom acknowledged that his Facebook-owned company has eliminated the ability to embed pictures in Twitter and intends to make posts to Twitter redirect users to Instagram to view images.

Share and share alike? Hardly. You promote, we monetize.

Social networking isn't about sharing. It's about marketing. Perhaps the most obvious proof of that is Facebook's promoted posts, through which advertisers can pay to have their marketing distributed more widely in Facebook users' news feeds.

Sharing at its best is private, personal and genuine. It's direct. It doesn't involve intermediaries. It doesn't have terms of service or privacy policies that describe how you will not be getting privacy. But public sharing is something else entirely. It's publishing, or something like it, paid for by free online services worth far less than the data surrendered and the labor required to produce it. But that's capitalism, isn't it? Buy low, sell high.

Continue reading at InfoWeek 

Thomas Claburn

Thomas Claburn
Thomas Claburn has been writing about business and technology since 1996, for publications such as New Architect, PC Computing, InformationWeek,...
Read Full Bio >>
See More From This Columnist >>

Content Manger

Manages on site content for the benefit of our viewers 

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter all the required information, indicated by an asterisk (*). HTML code is not allowed.

Testimonials | What Our Clients Says

Great job on updating our business site! It looks fresh and timely and now we are hooked up with all social media avenues which is so important today. We LOVE it!!



"Wow! Very professional. Best premiere view of a website I've seen in years." Just one of the many great comments I have gotten on my website. I really appreciate that you hung in there with me (creative minds do not always think The end result is just what I wanted!

Why Us | Quality, Value & Integrity

Our products are built from a business usabily mindset, automating the business processes you're currently doing manually, saving you time while increasing cost-effeciency.

Read more about the Company, management, and our philosophy

Our Company | Scalable SaaS and PaaS

Mailing Address
Incognito Worldwide
616 Corporate Way 
Suite 2-3784
Valley Cottage, NY 
10989 U.S.A. 

Call Centers
+1.646.233.4164 USA
+91.974 1161819 India 
+5411 4522 3678 Argentina